Sibling Rivalry
Chapter 6
by sammynona
To say the atmosphere as they left the car was tense would have been a disservice to the word tense. Paul was nearly at his wits end trying to stop Ruth, and he couldn’t even imagine what Mary was going through. Walking across the yard she was quiet, arms folded across her chest. Usually she’d be excitedly chatting about the latest gossip, and Paul would have given anything to see his girlfriend laughing and talking about the slutty girls at her job.
When she might be reacting poorly to the hypnotic commands, Paul would always sit her down and put her under, calm her down and take away whatever was troubling her. Usually that would involve giving her a fake memory to explain away what she was commanded to do, like replacing a mindlessly given blowjob during dinner with the happy memory of enjoying the Tiramisu they had for desert. Not just to hide the hypnosis from her, but also to stop her from questioning her own actions.
The problem was that Paul had no idea what Mary could remember from tonight. Was Ruth constantly triggering her making her lose track of what she was doing, or was she aware of how strangely she was behaving and had no way to explain it?
And while both of them were clearly uncomfortable, Ruth stalked imperiously behind them, a satisfied grin printed on her face. The sadistic sister was no doubt getting off on watching them both squirm.
Paul was just opening the door for Mary when he got the idea to just lock Ruth out. It was a useless move and he knew it, but he had to do something to try and get Mary alone. If he could be the one to explain that he’d been hypnotizing her without her knowing then there could at least be a chance at saving their relationship.
So as soon as they were inside Paul spun on his heel and tried to slam the door shut, hoping for a glimpse of shock on Ruth’s face to make it all worth it. Except Ruth didn’t seem surprised in the slightest. There was amusement in her eyes, and her mouth was already open to give the command. Even as he pushed the door shut with all his strength, it wasn’t fast enough to cut off the command.
“Maid Mary.”
Paul put his back against the closed door, and saw that Mary’s eyes had already gone blank, the command kicking in. It was the other trigger he’d told Ruth back at the restaurant. Part of him was hoping that Ruth had forgotten all about it.
There was a playful knock at the door, and Paul sighed in defeat as he opened it for Ruth. No point leaving her out there to make a scene for the whole neighborhood.
Ruth tittered and patted him on the cheek as she passed. “That was cute, really. But I’m not done with-” Ruth stopped, glancing around the living room for a sign of Mary, but she was gone.
Ruth spun in a panic. She managed to catch sight of Mary’s feet on the stairs as she marched out of view, and Ruth ran to the stairs with steam practically pouring out of her ears.
“Get back here!”
Mary didn’t even slow down as she vanished upstairs.
“I’m ordering you back here!”
“She can’t hear you,” Paul muttered. Of all the triggers she had to use it had to be this one. In this state Mary wouldn’t be able to hear his commands either, so there was no chance of getting her free now.
“What are you talking about?” Ruth stomped her foot, her dress swishing about her legs, and Paul had the impression of a spoiled girl throwing a tantrum. “You told me that trigger would make her my horny servant.”
“There’s… some setup first.”
Ruth narrowed her eyes. “You wouldn’t be trying to trick me. You’re not stupid enough for that.” But she kept glaring at him like a hawk, making it clear that Ruth definitely thought he was that stupid.
“Hey, I’m as pissed about this as you are.” They stood there staring each other down a few beats longer. Then Paul sighed and trudged into the kitchen. “You want a drink? She’ll be a few minutes.”
“Tell me what’s happening or I’ll march up there and tell her all about what you’ve been up to.”
“You can’t tell her anything for about an hour, so be my guest.” Paul turned his back on her and ignored her seething anger as he went to pour himself a drink. He let some ice clink into a glass, then got a second cup just in case. When he glanced over his shoulder he saw Ruth perched at the door of the kitchen. At least she appeared calmer.
“Seriously. What’s going on?”
“You should have let me explain how the trigger worked before you blurted it out.”
“I like to look before I leap. Makes life more interesting.”
“For you, anyway.” Paul handed her a drink, which she promptly brought up to her face and sniffed cautiously.
“Do you really think I have poison laying around?”
“No,” she said as she took a sip, and wrinkled her nose. “Just cheap whiskey.”
“When you bring out Maid Mary, it disables everything else. She’ll be in maid-mode for about an hour, and she’ll be completely submissive, except that Maid Mary doesn’t have any of her triggers. After an hour she’ll go back to normal with no memory of what happened.”
"You can't override it?"
"Never needed to."
"So what's she up to now?"
Paul smirked. “Do you really want me to ruin the surprise?”
For a moment Ruth clenched her hand tight around the glass, and Paul thought she was gonna throw it at him. Then she relaxed and barked out a laugh, before dropping down onto the couch in the living room.
"Guess it's fine waiting. I know there's nothing you can do to stop me, anyhow. I'll still be able to tell Mary all about your hypnosis setup after the hour's over."
"Yeah, but if you don't mind I'm gonna spend the next hour to relax, so go ahead and threaten me later."
He dropped down into a chair on the other side of the room, and pointedly shut his eyes. Let Ruth see how it felt to be ignored for a bit. It would probably drive a spoiled girl like her wild.
In the meantime he could use this hour to make a plan of action. He'd managed to get Ruth into trance, dammit, but that random phone call had to ruin everything. How much of his suggestions had sunk in? Clearly not enough, since Ruth was still planning to use and humiliate Mary when she came back. There had to be some way out.
He almost didn't hear the soft footsteps getting close, and opened his eyes just in time to see Ruth diving down on top of him. She landed hard in his lap, flashing a playful smile. He tried to shove her off, but Ruth planted a hand on either side of the chair and held on tight, like a stubborn cat.
"Oh come on, I thought you said you were going to lighten up."
"Having you in my lap isn't exactly my idea of relaxing, especially not with how you've been torturing us all night."
"First of all," Ruth said with a wag of her finger, "I haven't done anything to torture Mary. From the looks of it she's loved everything I've done to her."
"Because you conditioned her to like it."
"Tomato, tomato. And two, the only reason you aren't having fun is because you're being so damn stubborn. You could have let yourself just enjoy the blowjob in the car, but you had to act like even that was some evil thing you had to resist."
"I'm just not a fan of being blackmailed," Paul snapped, although at the mention of the blowjob he couldn't help but recall Mary's blank eyes staring up at him, worshipping his cock with devotion like he'd never seen. Against his wishes his cock started to get harder, and Ruth happily wriggled her ass down against it.
"Come on, this should be a blast for you. You've been using hypnosis to have fun with my sister, so what's so different? The only change is now you've got her hot, kinky twin sister wanting to fuck you too. Such a disaster."
"I've got her bitch of a sister trying to blackmail me. You're going to hold this over my head forever."
"That's one option," Ruth said, her voice suddenly hushed. She planted a hand on Paul's chest and rested her head on his shoulder, and Paul couldn't shake the deja vu hitting him, imagining that this was Mary curled up against him like she usually does. In this moment the menace was gone from her eyes, and Ruth almost looked cute.
"There's another option?” he asked, the question dripping with skepticism.
Ruth nodded. "You can accept it. You can accept me."
"What are you-"
"I'll promise to say nothing to Mary, but in return you date both of us. I get to fuck you, suck your cock, anything I want to do with you. And you can keep dating Mary and hypnotizing her to have your fun. How is that not a happy ending?"
"Because I won't cheat on my girlfriend."
Ruth cocked her head, green eyes boring into him, but Paul didn't flinch. He loved Mary, and as complicated as all of this was, he wasn't going to sleep with Ruth, no matter how tempting she made it seem.
Then that devious smile flashed back onto Ruth's face. "And what if she wanted you to date me too?"
"She wouldn't want that."
"I think you weren't paying attention. The whole time she was walking back into the house, did you notice that Mary was acting quiet?"
"Yeah, she's probably freaking out from doing all of that weird stuff for you.”
"Nope," Ruth tittered. "She was staring at you, or more specifically your cock. And she kept checking me out too. Biting her lip the whole time, hips squirming. She wants to fuck the both of us. My little suggestion seems to really be paying off."
"I doubt it," Paul said, only there wasn't any conviction in his voice. With all the fantasies Ruth had shoved in there, Mary might really be willing to change her views on incest and dating multiple people.
"We'll find out in an hour, anyway. When she turns back to normal I'll ask her point blank. No more games or tricks. Just, 'Hey sis, do you want Paul to date both of us so we can have hot threesomes all the time?’” Ruth snuggled herself in closer against Paul, sliding her head up against the crook of his neck. “And when she begs you to do that, I want you to accept it. Fuck the both of us and just embrace our new life together. I’ll let you do all your perverted fantasies to Mary still, and I’ll show you plenty of my own fantasies too. Maybe I’ll even let you do some of that stuff to me, too. We can be happy together. The three of us.”
Paul tensed up, knowing that she was right. This really would be the easiest way out. He doubted he could trust Ruth's word not to do anything to him, but would a life of dating both twins really be so awful? It might even… be a little fun.
Ruth made a tiny squeak and lifted up her hips, giggling as Paul’s hard cock poked her in the ass, betraying him. "Seems like someone likes the idea. Do yourself a favor and just think with your cock on this one."
The sharp clicking sound of heels descending the stairs behind them made Ruth and Paul turn. Paul already knew what was coming, but Ruth actually gasped and clapped her hands in delight. "No way!"
"Hello Sir. Hello Madame," Mary said with a practiced smile on her face, her hair pulled back into a ponytail now. She was decked out in a maid uniform that was really little more than lingerie, complete with fishnets covering her shapely legs and a set of tall stiletto heels. Mary curtsied for them like a good maid, and Ruth burst into applause.
"Paul, you might have gone for the cliche but it's fucking genius. Well done."
"Glad I could impress," Paul tried to say flippantly, only he did feel flattered. He was actually very proud of the work that had gone into constructing the maid personality in Mary's head. She was practically a completely separate woman when she was in this state. Submissive, dutiful, but also surprisingly gentle and playful. Whereas Mary was brash and open with her desires, the maid standing before them now was reserved, almost bashful of the perverted desires flowing through her. And Mary admitted in trance that she got off incredibly hard on the idea that Paul was a powerful man above her station that she was able to seduce. Leave it to Mary to figure out how to make a submissive maid into a power trip, but he was happy that she could enjoy herself.
Ruth leapt off of Paul's lap as she ran over to gush over Maid Mary's outfit. "Ugh, just look at this top, and the little skirt. What kind of panties do you have on? If you're wearing anything at all under there."
Ruth grabbed playfully to lift up Mary's skirt, and Mary went bright red as she stepped back, gripping the bottom of her skirt with both hands. "Madame, pleeease," she whined. "That's not appropriate."
"Maid, who's in charge here?"
Mary whimpered, but lifted her eyes up to meet Ruth's gaze. "You are, Madame, and Mister Paul."
"That's right. So if I want to see your panties, what will you do?"
Mary bit her lip and shuffled her feet awkwardly in her heels. As uncomfortable as she made a show of looking, Paul easily recognized the tells for when Mary was getting horny while she was a maid. She wanted to show off for Ruth. Which meant that Ruth might actually get away with all of this.
After a few more seconds of token resistance, Mary lifted up her skirt to show off the sheer black panties she wore underneath, the crotch removed to show off her dripping pink pussy lips. “I’ll obey, Madame. Forgive me for being impertinent."
"Perhaps some punishment is in order. Paul, do you think she deserves a spanking for being such a naughty girl?"
Mary let out an excited whimper, which only made Ruth’s evil grin grow wider.
"Oh, you like the idea of Paul spanking you, do you?"
Mary’s face managed to become even redder, hiding her hands behind her back as she tried to turn away. "O-of course not, Madame. It would be wrong."
"Because you're just a lowly little maid?" Ruth purred.
Mary turned and gave Ruth a quizzical look. "Because Paul is your husband, Madame."
Paul nearly spat out his drink, while Ruth shot him an absolutely gleeful look.
"We're married, huh? Lord and lady of the house, right?"
"Y-yes," Mary said, tilting her head. This was news to them, but in Mary's head it was would make perfect sense. To her Ruth and Paul were both the people she served, so it only made sense that she'd view them as a couple. Paul wasn't her boyfriend right now, and Ruth wasn't her sister. To Mary, they were the couple now. A couple she wanted to fuck.
Paul had to shut this down quick. "Mary, why don't you go clean upstairs while we-"
Ruth ran over and clapped a hand over his mouth, giving him a death glare. "Hey, we're trying to have fun here." Then she kissed the back of her hand, mimicking giving Paul a kiss. "Besides, I think it would be hot to watch my 'husband' fuck my maid."
Behind them Mary stammered, blushing madly. "That- Madame, I couldn't… I wouldn't… no matter how much I- I mean..."
Ruth turned and snapped her fingers. While she was in maid mode there wasn't a way to use any of her triggers on her, but Mary still went silent and stood at attention.
"Paul, do you want to fuck the help?"
Paul raised an eyebrow, wondering what she was up to. Surely it wouldn't be as simple as that.
Ruth rolled her eyes. In a whisper only he could hear, she said, "Dude, I'm trying to play nice here. Just take the chance to fuck Mary, you both probably need it."
With a heavy sigh, Paul relented. "Fine, I'll fuck her."
Maid Mary broke into an overjoyed smile, which she quickly tried to hide. She was supposed to pretend like she didn't want to fuck him, after all. "O-only if Madame really wants me to. I suppose I can-"
"Mary. Bend over the couch. This instant." Ruth pointed a manicured finger commandingly, and Paul was amazed at how fast Mary ran over to the couch in her ridiculous heels. In the blink of an eye she'd thrown herself over the top of the couch and thrust her ass high in the air, the skimpy skirt of her maid uniform hiding nothing at all from view.
Paul couldn't help himself from getting hard again.
"Go ahead, honey," Ruth said, giving him an encouraging pat on the ass. "I wanna watch you fuck her like she deserves."
Now Paul could see the trap, of course. Ruth was pretending that she could play nice. Trying to trick Paul into believing that if he handed both of them over to her, that she'd allow them to still fuck as a couple. It was all a lie. It had to be. Ruth would be the cruel mistress she'd shown herself to be. Surely it wouldn't really be like this.
Or would it?
Paul stripped, while traitorous thoughts ran through his head. Thoughts wondering if Ruth was really as bad as he thought she was. Maybe there really was a sweet side to her, buried under all that perversion. Maybe life with Ruth in charge of them wouldn't be so bad. If Mary really did want it, then could he?
He could only stall for so long though, before Mary was writhing on the couch, her pussy slick and inviting, and his cock throbbing and aching to be inside her. He glanced back at Ruth, shocked to see that she’d stripped naked as well. She'd dragged a chair around to get a better view, and now she sat with her legs spread, idly rubbing at her clit. She bit her thumb, grinning at him from ear to ear. An audience waiting to be impressed.
Somehow it was that edge of a challenge that pushed Paul over the edge. He grabbed Mary's hips and thrust into her. Mary threw her head back and moaned loudly in relief, and Paul was amazed at the greedy way Mary's pussy gripped his cock tight. All of Ruth’s teasing tonight must have made her truly desperate.
"More," Mary cried, rocking her ass back to grind against him. She paused, looking over her shoulder and smiled apologetically at him. "I mean, please sir. Puh-please fuck me more."
It was simply too adorable, seeing Mary so shy and sexy. He’d officially reached his limit.
Paul fucked her, obliging his hypnotized girlfriend as he let himself act on his own pent up need. Before he realized it he was fucking Mary with everything he had, nearly losing himself in the wonderful tight sensation of her pussy enveloping his cock, every move punctuated by a grateful cry from Mary. He wanted to let himself slip into that zone, to be so completely engrossed in making love with her that he would almost be in a trance himself. It would let him forget all about the perilous situation they were in, but Paul knew he couldn't let his guard down, even now.
Cautiously he peeked behind him, waiting to see Ruth's sly smile favoring him, an arrogant queen convinced that she was in complete control. And yet as clear of an image as it was in his head, Paul was taken back when he saw something completely different.
Ruth had nearly slipped out of the chair, her ass barely hanging off of the side as her fingers rubbed at her clit with a frantic need. Her knees were bent, like she were just about to slide off the chair and fall to the floor. Her eyes were glazed over, almost in a trance. Her breath was coming in deep, hectic hitches, and she was tugging on one of her nipples as hard as she could.
Ruth looked like a possessed woman. Paul lost his pace fucking Mary and his cock accidentally slipped out of her. All he could do was stare at Ruth and wonder what had come over her.
"More," Mary whined, humping the couch and wagging her ass in the air at him. "Sir, fuck me more!"
At the same time Ruth's face suddenly contorted, almost like she was in agony. "Fuck her," Ruth whimpered. She pinched her nipple hard and hissed in air. "Keep fucking her. Why would he stop?"
It was like Ruth had forgotten she was there. She was looking through Paul, and he realized her full attention was on Mary's face.
Paul quickly lined himself up and grabbed Mary's hips. This time he suddenly yanked her back against him and she shrieked with delight as he filled her again. Only Paul had never taken his eyes off of Ruth, and so he watched as she relaxed back into the blissfully blank face she had before.
He started to fuck Mary, and Ruth resumed fucking herself.
He changed to a slower, teasing pace, and Ruth immediately matched it, her hands practically shivering as she rubbed her clit in slow circles.
He spanked Mary's ass, making her give an adorable cry, and Ruth moaned, her eye’s rolling back.
What was happening? He knew that Ruth had fantasized about Mary for years. Was finally seeing her fuck someone making Ruth react like this?
"Yes, yes, more sir, please. Fuck me like the slut I am!"
Paul glanced down at Mary's face, and saw the absolute delight that she was lost in as she was fucked. Which is what finally made it click in Paul's head.
He'd only been able to hypnotize Ruth with one command: That making Mary happy would make her happy. So seeing Mary enjoying having her mind fucked out must be making Ruth so happy that she's practically fixated on it.
As soon as he pieced that together, Paul stopped holding back. He didn't really have a plan yet, but he knew fretting over Ruth wouldn't help. Making Mary happy was making Ruth vulnerable, and so he'd go all in.
He swept his arms around Mary and suddenly lifted her straight into the air. She laughed gleefully, but it quickly turned into a series of moans as Paul managed to keep fucking her, bouncing her up and down on his cock. The whole time he made sure that Ruth had an excellent view of Mary's face. Before long Mary went quiet, the only sounds in the room the wet noises of her being fucked, and Paul knew that meant she was close to cumming, the calm before the storm.
Though his arms were aching, he kept a firm grip on Mary, taking her deeper and hitting the spot she knew she loved most in this position. It worked like magic, and Mary suddenly shouted out in orgasm, cursing and moaning and thanking him incoherently.
Paul checked on Ruth, expecting to her to be cumming to, but instead Ruth had gone still. She was staring at Mary in awe, like someone standing before a masterpiece of art.
Paul held Mary against her, giving her a few moments to relax and come down from her climax, before he slipped his cock out of her and set her down on shaky legs. It was no use, though, as Mary 's legs almost immediately gave out, and he caught her just in time to stop her from falling, but that just brought both of them down to the floor in an unceremonious heap. Mary gave him an apologetic look, then burst out laughing, and Paul couldn't help but laugh too as they sat there on the floor. In that moment Paul forgot all about Ruth and the blackmail and everything else going on. They were just two people in love and drunk on each other's presence.
"Ahem," Mary said, tucking her skirt back into place, returning to her professional demeanor despite the fact that she was flat on her ass with her legs spread, his cum dripping out of her. "Thank you very much, sir. That was wonderful."
"Yeah," Paul said, still recovering and having trouble forming words.
There was a groan nearby, and Paul and Mary glanced up in surprise to see Ruth sitting only a few feet away. She had her legs clenched tight together, her hand cupping her pussy and her eyes wide. She seemed at a complete loss of words.
"Did you enjoy watching me cum, Madame?"
Ruth nodded slowly, like a rusty machine struggling to move.
"Do you want Paul to fuck you now, Madame?"
Paul's breath caught in his throat. He hadn't been expecting that. He sputtered, wanting to get an excuse out, except he saw Ruth shaking her head back and forth. She still had that far away, unbelieving look in her eyes.
Mary cocked her head and sat up a little straighter. "What do you want then, Madame?"
Ruth blinked, a little life returning back to her eyes. "I… I want…” She shuddered, blushing. "Want you happy."
Mary smiled. “I’m very happy. Paul's cock is everything I fantasized it would be."
Ruth stared at Paul now, and he felt an uneasy chill run down his spine. Somehow this eerily blank Ruth seemed just as dangerous as the cunning bitch who had been torturing him all night.
"You… make her happy," Ruth muttered. She said the words as if they were strange in her mouth, like they shouldn’t possibly fit together.
"I do," Paul said, wary but unable to keep hope from filling him. The whole night Ruth had been looking at them from the position of how she could manipulate them both to get what she wanted. But now all Ruth wanted was Mary's happiness, and she'd just seen first hand how happy he made her. Would she give up? Could this be it?
"Your cock… makes her happy."
Mary's face went red, and she giggled. "It does, Madame."
Ruth looked back and forth between Paul and Mary, her lips tight and brow furrowed. Finally, she seemed to come to a decision. "Fuck her again."
"What?" Paul and Mary asked at the same time.
Now Ruth shivered, and he noticed that she’d resumed rubbing her pussy. For the first time since they'd met, Ruth was acting shy, almost reserved. “Please… fuck Mary again.”
Paul felt a hand on his shoulder as Mary slid next to him, grinning wide. Somehow she’d already managed to strip off the top of the fake maid uniform. "If Madame insists, I must obey."
“I insist too,” Paul said with a playful growl, and Mary squealed with delight as he pinned Mary down to the ground. Mary was panting, legs already spread, and Paul glanced back at Ruth with a smirk on his face. She was still touching herself, as he’d expected. He’d show Ruth what Mary enjoyed, and then she’d have no choice but to give up on the whole idea of owning them both. Ruth would realize that Mary was happiest being his alone, and the programming he’d given her would make her back off, the way a good sister should.
And there was no reason he couldn’t enjoy himself more, too.
Mary was already lifting her hips up, waiting for Paul to slide inside of her, but instead Paul rolled over onto his back. He got into a comfortable position, and Mary’s eyes lit up with understanding as she saw his cock standing at attention.
“Ride me, Mary. Make it a good show.”
“Anything for you, Sir,” Mary said as she straddled his lap, hovering her dripping pussy just above his cock. She brushed her hair back and guided herself down slowly, not using her hands as she let the head of his cock run along her pussy lips. She kept narrowly missing, but neither of them cared. They were staring into each other’s eyes, smiling easily. Even in a hypnotized state, Mary’s body knew exactly how to please them both.
And all the while Ruth could only stare, literally on the edge of her seat as she watched them and masturbated.
Unable to take it anymore, Paul finally grabbed Mary’s hips and brought her down onto his waiting cock. They both moaned with relief, and Mary began to ride him at an urgent pace. Hips pumping, breasts bouncing; every time she was on top Paul could only marvel at how beautiful Mary was. Her eyes were full of lust now. Mary reached down and ran her nails along his chest, bouncing on his cock with more urgency.
“So good,” she moaned, and Paul smirked over at Ruth. The longer they fucked, the more Ruth seemed to be drained of her power. Gone was the image of her as the dominant blackmailer— now Paul only saw a horny girl watching them enviously as they fucked.
Mary caught him watching and she turned, never losing the steady rhythm of riding Paul. “Do you like watching me fuck him, Madame?”
Ruth actually flinched like she’d just been caught peeping. She jerked her hand away from her pussy, and averted her gaze. “Y-yeah.”
Paul saw his chance and took it. He slapped Mary on the ass, and as she cried out happily in surprise, Ruth shuddered, still affected by her sister’s happiness. “You love riding my cock, don’t you, Mary?”
“Yes, Sir! More than anything!” Mary picked up the pace, throwing her head back as she fucked Paul with abandon.
He gave Ruth a pointed look. “She sure looks happy, doesn’t she?”
Hearing that, Ruth couldn’t stop herself from letting out a rattling moan. “She doooeeess.”
“And don’t you want to do anything that’ll make her happy?”
For a brief moment, Ruth’s eyes narrowed. She bore into him with that cold, calculating stare of hers, and he wondered if she’d figured out the conditioning. But then she blinked and it was gone. Ruth’s shoulders slumped in defeat.
“I guess… I should only be trying to make her happy.” Ruth gulped, the guilt of her actions hanging over her. This was it! They were actually free. “I- Paul, I’m sor-”
“Oh fuck,” Mary cried, oblivious to everything happening around her. She suddenly whipped her head around and gave Ruth a delirious smile. “You should join us.”
Ruth’s mouth dropped. “You want me to-”
“Please fuck me,” Mary said, and Paul’s hopes crashed and burned. “Please fuck Paul! I want to make you both so happy!”
Ruth got up, hesitantly, still caught in her guilty trance. “But… you don’t really want…”
Before Paul could stop her, Mary reached out and wrapped an arm around Ruth’s waist. She pulled her twin sister in close and dove between her legs, licking her pussy excitedly.
Ruth moaned in relief, and Paul watched as that shy attitude vanished. Ruth had nearly come to believe that Mary was happiest with Paul alone, but that was hard to believe when Mary was eating her out as if her pussy were the most delicious thing she’s ever tasted.
“Mary,” Paul said, carefully, “Maybe we should just focus on us.”
Mary pulled back, her chin slick with her sister’s cunt, and shook her head. “Fuck no. I want to see you both fucking. So bad.”
Ruth grinned now, but still stood beside them, not making a move on her own. “What should I do?” she asked, sounding surprisingly submissive. “What will make you happiest?”
Mary’s eyes lit up. “Fucking Paul!” But then she stared down at herself, almost surprised to find that she was still riding him. And she was fucking him intensely, almost more than Paul could bear. “But I don’t want to give up this cock,” Mary whined. Somehow seeing Mary so torn about which of them should be fucking him was only getting Paul more turned on, but he knew they couldn’t have a threesome. He had to get Ruth out of here before she could trick Mary into becoming her slave to humiliate.
“Mary, why don’t we let Ruth watch us, and then we can-”
Mary clenched her pussy tight, cutting Paul off as he groaned in delight. Then Mary broke into a wide grin. “Paul can eat you out. Please, Madame, ride his face!”
Paul tried to push Mary off, but Ruth was instantly on top of him, surprisingly strong as she pinned him to the floor. Ruth’s face was lit up with excitement, and he saw her incredibly wet cunt just inches away from his face.
“Anything to make you happy,” Ruth told her sister, her earlier reservations vanished. Whatever effect his command had had on her before was clearly broken. Ruth was back to her normal self, and Paul could only get half of a warning out before she planted herself on his face, smothering his words with her dripping cunt.
Paul felt too weak to fight as Mary rode him desperately, fucking him so intensely that she was practically draining him. And he resisted eating Ruth out, but he was running out of air and had no choice. As soon as he began to lick Ruth lifted her hips, giving him a chance to breath as he ate her out. Anytime his tongue stopped, or even went too slow for her taste, she would drop her ass back down on his head and smother him.
And the whole time they rode him Ruth and Mary were talking, their voices muffled by Ruth’s thighs clamped tight against the sides of Paul’s head. He could only catch snippets of words, and none of it was good.
“So sexy… you love… serve us.”
“Yes! Yes, I must… only exist to… good servant.”
“… me cum. Don’t stop. Make-”
Suddenly Mary’s pussy tightened around his cock, and even smothered by Ruth he could hear her crying out in orgasm. At the same moment Ruth’s legs squeezed tight around him, her cunt dripping delicious juices into his mouth, the taste sweeter than Mary’s pussy, and as both twins came Paul couldn’t help but groan and cum inside Mary, cock twitching as she continued to ride him, milking his cock with everything she had.
Time blurred, lost in the darkness and the afterglow of cumming so hard, and when Ruth finally let him free Paul felt disoriented. It took his eyes a few seconds to adjust to the light, but then he saw them sitting nearby, Mary and Ruth kissing each other passionately, Ruth’s hand caressing her sister’s throat. And Mary was keening into the touch, thrusting out her tits as an offering.
“Now then,” Ruth said, that cruel strength back in her voice. “Let’s figure out how else you can serve me.”
And Mary only grinned, lovingly staring into Ruth’s eyes. “Anything for you… Mistress.”
Paul could only lay there, naked and spent, as he muttered, “Fuck.”
Good news! Sibling Rivalry Chapter 7 is now up on my patreon and I’m working hard on completing the next chapter for it and Donna’s Trance Trigger soon. Anyone in my discord server or following me on social media might have heard that I’ve spent the last three years recovering from a dual wrist injury that’s stopped me from writing for a long time. Unfortunately it means I had to extend the hiatus on stories like this one, but I’m getting back to work writing and editing and I’m hoping that I’ll be able to resume work on the big series soon. I’m still struggling to cover bills and rent from being out of work so if you want to see more chapters of this series and others it would be a big help to have your support on my patreon!
f you enjoy the series and want to see more of my writing while supporting me you can go to my patreon, which I can’t link directly, but you can join my discord server and see announcements on all new stories, along with everything else Sammynona going on in the world. You can also check out my official bluesky page: https://bsky.app/profile/sammynona.bsky.social